Young Mufasa screams in Mufasa: The Lion King
Screenshot via Walt Disney Studios

Why are Disney fans already accusing ‘Mufasa’ of ruining ‘The Lion King?’

Disney should've been prepared for this.

Disney, you deliberately disobeyed us. And, what’s worse, you put the legacy of The Lion King in danger!

Recommended Videos

Even though every Disney fan and their (Pluto the) dog detested the “live-action” remake when it came out in 2019, they must’ve all gone to see it anyway, as its $1 billion box office earnings ensured a follow-up has emerged from the elephant’s graveyard that is Disney’s IP vaults. The first trailer for Mufasa, a prequel focusing on Simba’s ill-fated pops, at least teases slightly more emotive animals this time and it does have an original story behind it.

Or does it? Hardcore Lion King subjects know that the origins of Mufasa and Scar have already been told. So the way that Disney is ripping up the source material with this new film is leaving them as angry as a pack of slobbering, mangy, stupid hyenas (ix-nay on the upidstay).

Mufasa is rewriting The Lion King origins from top to bottom

Mufasa and Scar face to face in The Lion King
Screenshot via Walt Disney Animation Studios

When Disney elected to move forward with a Mufasa prequel, they probably thought they were in the clear — after all, Mufasa and Scar’s childhood is not discussed at length in the original 1994 animation so surely the fans would cut them some slack with this one, right? Wrong! Clearly, the studio underestimated their own fandom’s loyalty to long-forgotten ’90s tie-in merchandise.

Mufasa and Scar’s origins have been told before, just not in film. 1994’s comic book series A Tale of Two Brothers depicts how Scar went from respected prince to villainous schemer. Born Taka, Mufasa’s little brother’s jealousy led him to convince a cruel buffalo named Boma and his herd to attack his sibling, but the buffalo attacked Scar instead. Although saved by Mufasa, Taka gained a scar across his eye, and decided to rechristen himself in honor of it.

An alternate origin, meanwhile, is depicted in the Disney Junior spinoff series The Lion Guard, in which Scar’s real name was instead given as Askari. Due to nostalgia and the fans’ general dislike for the kid-friendly series, A Tale of Two Brothers has renamed the canon backstory for the Lion Princes, though. So the fact that Mufasa is directly borrowing the Taka name but changing everything else about it is infuriating some fans.

In Mufasa, we’re told that Simba’s father was not born into royalty and it was Scar who was actually the oldest son of the king of the Pride Lands. The film’s story sees Scar even welcome Mufasa into his family once the young cub becomes an orphan following a tragic flood. Not only does this contradict the specifics of Tale and the intricacies of Scar’s personality, it also misses the clever double-meaning of the villain’s real name. In Swahili, Taka means “waste,” belying his nature as the second royal son, aka the spare. Whatever the incarnation, the root of Scar’s resentment comes from living in Mufasa’s shadow his whole life. But not anymore apparently.

But the biggest crime, if you ask Lion King loyalists, is making Mufasa a commoner. Is Disney trying to gaslight us into forgetting much of Mufasa’s dialogue in the original film? A glance at the YouTube comments to the trailer reveals many disgruntled reactions. “’Without a drop of nobility’ so this movie literally retcons Mufasa’s whole conversation with Simba, making him the first king of the Pride Lands,” wrote one. “Mufasa was definitely nobility. He kind of explained he was from a line of kings when talking to Simba,” shared another. “I’m not sure what they’re doing here.”

What is Disney doing here? Probably attempting to make a Pumbaa-sized pile of money while leaving your lifelong affection for The Lion King to get trampled under a herd of stampeding wildebeest (what? Too soon? JK, I know, it’s always too soon).


We Got This Covered is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more
related content
Read Article Will there be a ‘Cars 4’?
The many characters of the Cars franchise
Read Article ‘Star Wars’: How Old Was Padmé In Episode 1?
Read Article Is there a ‘Cruella 2’ release date?
Emma Stone as Cruella in the 2021 'Cruella' live-action movie.
Read Article How many Disney movies has Lin-Manuel Miranda now written music for?
Lin-Manuel Miranda attends Disney Studios' premiere of "Encanto" at El Capitan Theatre on November 03, 2021 in Los Angeles, California.
Read Article ‘Someone should do a documentary on this’: Disney World employee comes clean on how it ‘ruined’ her mental health and well-being
Side by side images of Kassie watching fireworks at Disneyworld, crying in a car, and posing for a photo.
Related Content
Read Article Will there be a ‘Cars 4’?
The many characters of the Cars franchise
Read Article ‘Star Wars’: How Old Was Padmé In Episode 1?
Read Article Is there a ‘Cruella 2’ release date?
Emma Stone as Cruella in the 2021 'Cruella' live-action movie.
Read Article How many Disney movies has Lin-Manuel Miranda now written music for?
Lin-Manuel Miranda attends Disney Studios' premiere of "Encanto" at El Capitan Theatre on November 03, 2021 in Los Angeles, California.
Read Article ‘Someone should do a documentary on this’: Disney World employee comes clean on how it ‘ruined’ her mental health and well-being
Side by side images of Kassie watching fireworks at Disneyworld, crying in a car, and posing for a photo.
Author
Christian Bone
Christian Bone is a Staff Writer/Editor at We Got This Covered and has been cluttering up the internet with his thoughts on movies and TV for over a decade, ever since graduating with a Creative Writing degree from the University of Winchester. As Marvel Beat Leader, he can usually be found writing about the MCU and yet, if you asked him, he'd probably say his favorite superhero film is 'The Incredibles.'